Outrageous claims about memorizing without using techniques never fail to sadden me.
Why people pander to mythologies, I’ll never know.
Especially when there is so much glory to be siphoned from the not-so-secret sauce of mnemonics.
But without further woo woo adieu, here’s today’s Q&A:
I like your MMM System, and I am learning and following it bit by bit.
But I have one doubt.
In India the Swami Vivekananda and some people now read a book page by page without use any mnemonics techniques, and are still able to recall all of the concepts and vocabulary words.
Simply they saying only by only concentration.
Which memory technique is this?
Is this better than mnemonics or journey system?
How do I develop this type of memory?
Thank you for your reply.
If these people are actually doing this through concentration, then I guess you would call this memory technique … “concentration.”
Concentration does actually work to help you form memories. It’s also a great way to connect new information to older information that you’ve already learned.
I can’t tell you if this is better or worse than any other system of memorizing material, but I can speculate that these people are probably not being honest and their claims would probably not stand up to scrutiny through scientific testing.
Merely concentrating on a book would help me personally learn material from it, but I would not truly “memorize” much from it. In order to actually memorize a lot of material from a book, I would use my textbook memorization system. I teach it here:
Quite frankly, there are so many advantages to this method that I would sooner have people who are serious about learning take these extra steps rather than experimenting with the quite likely woo woo claims of the Swamis.
In the case of the person you’re talking about, he was called a srutidhara which in English means someone who has an eidetic or photographic memory.
A lot of people believe in photographic memory (something that doesn’t seem to exist), but what they don’t know is that eidetic memory has only been scientifically demonstrated as valid for a couple of minutes.
Can you work on developing an eidetic memory?
Heck, these day’s there’s even an eidetic memory app …
But why bother fooling around with software when you can work on developing a Magnetic memory and retain information for the long haul.
Better than merely retaining it, you can turn raw information into knowledge.
Heck, if you write about the stuff that you’ve memorize, you might even wind up changing lives with ideas that only you can come up with because only you have put them together in the unique way that only you can …
… but only if you stop chasing after useless fantasies and worrying about which memory method or style is better than the other.
The only memory method that matters is the memory method that gets results.
If concentration works for these dudes, rock and roll.
Good for them.
I don’t buy it.
But I ain’t exactly going to stampede scientists over there to test their claims. James Randi has a million dollar prize for them if they can demonstrate that their super powers of concentration are true on a page by page basis.
That’s a lot of coin, so it’s hard to believe that they’re not rushing over to get tested. That says everything to me.
After all, haven’t they read and concentrated upon and remembered the famous James Randi prize? The prize has been terminated since I originally wrote this post, but it’s still worth knowing about and considering for its longterm promotion of critical thinking and the grants it will be distributing to this end moving forward.
In the meantime, I’ll stick with memory techniques that can, have and will in the future continue to be tested.
And I’ll keep on hanging around with dudes like Phil Chambers, Chief Arbiter of the World Memory Championships.
These people know and respect the limits of memory while constantly pushing it through training that is inspired by the many seductions of competition.
But you don’t have to compete to get the science of memory techniques working on your side.
The formula is simple:
1. Build at least one Memory Palace
2. Put information inside of it
3. Recall the information
(Optional: Synthesize the information and use it to improve the world).
Hope this helps!